• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Institute of Australian Culture

Heritage, history, and heroes; literature, legends, and larrikins

  • Home
  • Articles
  • Biographies
  • Books
  • Ephemera
  • Poetry & songs
    • Recommended poetry
    • Poetry and songs, 1786-1900
    • Poetry and songs, 1901-1954
    • Rock music and pop music [videos]
    • Early music [videos]
  • Slang
  • Timeline
    • Timeline of Australian history and culture
    • Calendar of Australian history and culture
    • Significant events and commemorative dates
  • Topics

Tinkering with defence [6 November 1929]

4 February 2022 · Leave a Comment

[Editor: This article, about defence matters, was published in The Sydney Mail (Sydney, NSW), 6 November 1929.]

Tinkering with defence

Certain considerations leap to the mind in reviewing Mr. Scullin’s announced suspension of Compulsory Military Training, which for twenty years has been the salient feature of our defence programme. Political pressure is, of course, the reason for it. The Labour Party produced the system. The feature of compulsion was hailed as an illustration of the capacity for self-discipline inherent in our most enlightened of democracies. But that high plane has been gradually abandoned, and all that Labour politicians can now see is that young voters and voters-about-to-be complain of the “hardships” of the system.

Even so it would seem that the Cabinet’s decision is unduly precipitate. Drills and camps were first officially discontinued. Subsequently a conference with defence officials is to be held with the object of devising something to lake their place. Such action appears to be a rather wilful putting of the cart before the horse.

Outside the ranks of officialdom Australia possesses men of undoubted military genius, even though they are anything but militaristic in outlook. Sir John Monash is, perhaps, the outstanding example. Had the Labour Government been wholly sincere in its desire to improve our defence programme a commission composed of experienced officers in whatever walk of life might have been created. The report of such a commission would have won the confidence of the Australian people.

As it is consultations with the officials of the Department of Defence will take place with a fait accompli as their basis. Any plan now evolved must function within the restricted circle of the Government’s desires, or rather of the desires of the Government’s more vociferous supporters.

Hints are thrown out that there will be some return to the old volunteer system. Putting completely on one side the undemocratic character of this procedure, it is worth remembering that the requirements of modern mechanical warfare are so exacting as to elude the dilettante efforts of the occasional amateur. It may be that the development of the aeroplane demands some modification be made in this view. Certainly it is true that a volunteer aerial force would attract plenty of volunteers. But just as certainly is it true that the defence of Australia cannot be wholly secured by an aerial force. In the war the value of the aeroplane was as that of the eye to the body. To be all eye and no body is useless. During the recent manoeuvres of the British Battle Fleet exhaustive tests of the aerial arm were made with a view of judging its effectiveness against warships. The results were indecisive. Again, the success of the aeroplane in desert fighting against savages is no criterion of its usefulness against civilised foes similarly equipped. There is one other factor in Australia’s defence problem which should receive due consideration. In one real sense Australia is compelled to stand aloof from the movement towards disarmament which is inspiring the statesmen of older nations. By her adherence to the White Australia policy Australia constantly reiterates a challenge to a large portion of the world.

But the very evolution of liberalism which is bringing disarmament within the range of practical politics is making it increasingly difficult to maintain Australia’s attitude on this question. Hitherto British statesmen have given their support, though sometimes reluctantly, to Australia’s most characteristic aspiration. But recent events at Geneva show that the Empire is no longer to be regarded as a unity in foreign policy. If the Dominions are tending to become national units they must show themselves ready to maintain their individual policies, and when that policy is necessarily provocative, it is obvious that its maintenance must be attended by a certain willingness to shoulder the burdens thus entailed.



Source:
The Sydney Mail (Sydney, NSW), 6 November 1929, p. 7

Editor’s notes:
criterion = a condition, fact, factor, principle, rule, standard, or test by which people, situations, or things may be assessed, compared, considered, evaluated, or judged; a standard used as the basis for a decision or judgment (“criterion” is singular, whereas “criteria” is plural; “criterions” is plural, although that term is rarely used)

dilettante = an amateur or dabbler; someone who engages in an area or field as a hobby, as an amusement, or as a matter of casual or superficial interest, and whose knowledge and understanding of it is not likely to be high (compared to a professional, who is paid to work in an area or field, with appropriately training, and a high level of knowledge and understanding)

Dominion = (in the context of the British Empire) one of the British Dominions (Australia, Canada, the Irish Free State, Newfoundland, New Zealand, South Africa), being those countries of the British Empire which were self-governed

fait accompli = (French) an accomplished fact; something accomplished which is apparently irreversible

John Monash = Sir John Monash (1865-1931), a civil engineer, and a leading Australian army general during the First World War

precipitate = to make something happen abruptly, quickly or suddenly; to make something happen sooner than expected, or sooner than normal; to bring about something hastily or prematurely (e.g. to do something when circumstances are not right, when essential or key elements are not ready, or when it is not sensible to do so)

salient = conspicuous, prominent, of notable significance, noteworthy, most important, most noticeable, something noticeable compared with its surroundings (may also refer to: jutting, pointing, projecting, or protruding outward or upward; jumping, leaping; in heraldry: an animal standing on its hind legs with its forelegs raised, as if in the act of leaping; an outward bulge of a military position on its front line with the enemy)

vociferous = characterised by a loud or noisy clamor or outcry, especially expressing an opinion repeatedly in a determined, energetic, forceful and/or vehement manner

Filed Under: articles Tagged With: 500x500, compulsory military training, defence, publication The Sydney Mail (Sydney), SourceTrove, White Australia, year1929

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Australian flag, Kangaroo, Wattle, 100hThe Institute of Australian Culture
Heritage, history, and heroes. Literature, legends, and larrikins. Stories, songs, and sages.

Search this site

Featured books

The Man from Snowy River and Other Verses, by Banjo Paterson A Book for Kids, by C. J. Dennis  The Bulletin Reciter: A Collection of Verses for Recitation from The Bulletin The Songs of a Sentimental Bloke, by C. J. Dennis The Complete Inner History of the Kelly Gang and Their Pursuers, by J. J. Kenneally The Foundations of Culture in Australia, by P. R. Stephensen The Australian Crisis, by C. H. Kirmess Such Is Life, by Joseph Furphy
More books (full text)

Featured lists

Timeline of Australian history and culture
A list of significant Australiana
Significant events and commemorative dates
Australian slang
Books (full text)
Australian literature
Rock music and pop music (videos)
Folk music and bush music (videos)
Early music (videos)
Recommended poetry
Poetry and songs, 1786-1900
Poetry and songs, 1901-1954
Australian explorers
Topics
Links

Featured posts

Advance Australia Fair: How the song became the Australian national anthem
Brian Cadd [music videos and biography]
Ned Kelly: Australian bushranger
Under the Southern Cross I Stand [the Australian cricket team’s victory song]

Some Australian authors

E. J. Brady
John Le Gay Brereton
C. J. Dennis
Mary Hannay Foott
Joseph Furphy
Mary Gilmore
Charles Harpur
Grant Hervey
Lucy Everett Homfray
Rex Ingamells
Henry Kendall
“Kookaburra”
Henry Lawson
Jack Moses
“Dryblower” Murphy
John Shaw Neilson
John O’Brien (Patrick Joseph Hartigan)
“Banjo” Paterson
Marie E. J. Pitt
A. G. Stephens
P. R. Stephensen
Agnes L. Storrie (Agnes L. Kettlewell)

Recent Posts

  • Dee from Invercauld [postcard, 28 August 1913]
  • Sydney Town Hall [postcard, 20 June 1913]
  • Flinders Lane, Melbourne [postcard, 26 April 1913]
  • Have you ever had a dream like this [postcard, 15 April 1913]
  • A loving greeting [postcard, 15 April 1913]

Top Posts & Pages

  • Poetry and songs, 1786-1900
  • The Man from Snowy River [poem by Banjo Paterson]
  • Rommel’s comments on Australian soldiers [1941-1942]
  • Australian slang
  • Timeline of Australian history and culture

Archives

Categories

Posts of note

The Bastard from the Bush [poem, circa 1900]
A Book for Kids [by C. J. Dennis, 1921]
Click Go the Shears [traditional Australian song, 1890s]
Core of My Heart [“My Country”, poem by Dorothea Mackellar, 24 October 1908]
Freedom on the Wallaby [poem by Henry Lawson, 16 May 1891]
The Man from Ironbark [poem by Banjo Paterson]
Nationality [poem by Mary Gilmore, 12 May 1942]
The Newcastle song [music video, sung by Bob Hudson]
No Foe Shall Gather Our Harvest [poem by Mary Gilmore, 29 June 1940]
Our pipes [short story by Henry Lawson]
Rommel’s comments on Australian soldiers [1941-1942]
Shooting the moon [short story by Henry Lawson]

Recent Comments

  • rob buntine on No Foe Shall Gather Our Harvest [poem by Mary Gilmore, 29 June 1940]
  • Carol on Poetry and songs, 1786-1900
  • Annie Crestani on Under the Southern Cross I Stand [the Australian cricket team’s victory song]
  • Peter Pearsall on The Clarence [poem by Jack Moses]
  • Trevor Hurst on Timeline of Australian history and culture

For Australia

Copyright © 2023 · Log in